Off-the-Clock Work in Healthcare: Legal Obligations and Best Practices to Protect Staff Wellbeing

Off-the-Clock Work in Healthcare: Legal Obligations and Best Practices to Protect Staff Wellbeing

Hook: Healthcare employers face a dual risk that keeps HR leaders awake at night: mounting legal exposure from unpaid “off-the-clock” work and a quieter crisis—staff burnout driven by invisible, uncompensated hours. The two are linked. Addressing one protects the other.

Key takeaway (most important first)

In late 2025 and early 2026 federal and state enforcement activity highlighted how common failures—poor timekeeping, permissive scheduling, and weak manager training—translate quickly into costly judgments and damaged workforce morale. Immediate priorities: (1) verify accurate time capture for all nonexempt staff, (2) strengthen scheduling and on-call policies, (3) run regular audits tied to operational KPIs, and (4) remediate pay errors transparently.

Why this matters now (2026 context)

Regulatory enforcement intensified in 2025 and continued into 2026. A notable example: the U.S. Department of Labor’s Wage and Hour Division secured a consent judgment against North Central Health Care (entered Dec. 4, 2025) requiring $162,486 in back wages and liquidated damages after case managers worked unrecorded hours from June 2021 to June 2023. That case is emblematic of several late-2025 actions targeting healthcare employers for overtime violations and inadequate recordkeeping.

Concurrently, state-level labor standards—especially around predictive scheduling, meal and rest breaks, and telework time capture—expanded in several jurisdictions. In 2026 employers must manage overlapping federal and state rules plus rising scrutiny of algorithmic scheduling and third-party staffing platforms.

Legal foundations: What employers must get right

At minimum, healthcare employers need to comply with:

• Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA): pay nonexempt employees at least the federal minimum wage, and time-and-one-half for hours worked in excess of 40 in a workweek; maintain accurate records of hours worked.
• State labor laws: many states have lower thresholds, daily overtime, predictive scheduling mandates, or stricter meal/rest break rules.
• Collective bargaining agreements: union contracts often contain premium pay, reporting/claim procedures, and grievance timelines.
• Anti-retaliation protections: employees who assert wage claims are protected from adverse action.

Common legal failure points in healthcare include: off-the-clock charting or EMR work, uncompensated travel between facilities, required but unpaid training, late shift handoff work, and understaffing that forces employees to continue work without clocking in. These failures are highly visible to investigators because they recur across organizations and create easily documented pay disparities.

Practical, actionable roadmap for immediate risk reduction

The steps below are prioritized for speed and impact. Implement them in the listed order and assign owners with deadlines.

1. Run a focused timekeeping and payroll audit (30–60 days)

• Scope: sample payroll across high-risk groups—case managers, nurses, behavioral health staff, telehealth clinicians, home health workers, agency temps.
• Data needed: clock-in/clock-out records, EHR access logs, scheduling data, overtime approvals, PTO records, and exception reports for a 12–24 month lookback.
• Method: match time card data against EHR login timestamps and shift schedules to identify unrecorded preshift/postshift work and repetitive rounding down of hours. For an organized approach to tools and consolidation before a deep audit, see guidance on auditing and consolidating your tool stack.
• Red flags: consistent patterns of missing minutes at shift start/end, frequent edits post-payroll, high volume of “off-the-clock” exceptions, and supervisory approval of uncompensated work.
• Deliverable: prioritized list of probable pay errors, estimated back pay exposure, and recommended remediation steps.

2. Stabilize time capture systems (60–90 days)

Key objective: eliminate gaps between work performed and time recorded.

• Enforce a single source of truth for hours worked. If multiple systems exist (EHR, badge scans, phone apps), define a reconciliation protocol and designate a primary system for payroll.
• Use modern timekeeping tools that integrate with EHRs and scheduling software. In 2026, expect greater adoption of EHR and timekeeping integration, geofencing for home health and telehealth time capture and secure biometric options where state law permits.
• Standardize rules on rounding: if you permit rounding, apply it uniformly and document the policy, ensuring it cannot systematically underpay employees.
• Define compensable time: clarify rules for pre-shift warm-up, charting, patient callbacks, travel between sites, and mandatory training. Convert verbal expectations into policy language.

3. Tighten scheduling and on-call practices

Scheduling decisions drive unpaid work and burnout. Rework rules to ensure fairness and compliance.

• Adopt or update a written overtime and on-call policy that details how on-call hours are compensated, when call constitutes compensable work, and how offsite telehealth call-outs are handled.
• Consider predictive scheduling best practices: publish schedules with minimum notice windows, pay shift-posting premiums for last-minute changes, and compensate for mandatory standby time where state law requires.
• Limit mandatory overtime and document the business need when used. Where staffing requires frequent mandatory overtime, analyze staffing models and agency reliance.
• Use scheduling analytics and AI-enabled forecasting (a 2026 trend) to reduce unexpected understaffing and the need for uncompensated coverage.

4. Train managers and frontline staff (ongoing)

• Develop short, role-specific training: managers must approve hours only when accurate; staff must record time contemporaneously.
• Teach supervisors to recognize and stop off-the-clock practices—e.g., asking staff to finish charting after clock-out.
• Include scenario-based modules: telehealth callbacks, travel between clinics, mandatory trainings, and meal break handling.
• Reinforce anti-retaliation messaging and provide anonymous reporting channels for timekeeping concerns.

5. Create a remediation playbook for discovered violations

A consistent remediation process reduces litigation risk and demonstrates good faith to regulators.

• Notify affected employees promptly and transparently. Explain the findings, the proposed remedy, and how back wages will be calculated and paid.
• Offer timely, interest-bearing payments and correct payroll records. Keep copies of communications and proof of payment.
• Document corrective actions: new policies, systems changes, retraining, and follow-up audit schedules.
• When in doubt, consult employment counsel before communicating broadly about legal exposure.

Operational policies: specific clauses and language to include

The following language examples are practical and defense-minded. Customize to your organization and review with legal counsel.

Timekeeping policy essentials

• Employees must record all hours worked contemporaneously in the designated timekeeping system.
• Employees are prohibited from performing uncompensated work. Managers must not instruct or allow employees to work off-the-clock.
• All adjustments to time records require documentation and supervisor approval. Payroll will retain adjustment records for a minimum of three years.

Overtime and premium pay

• Nonexempt employees will be paid time-and-one-half for hours worked over 40 in a workweek, or as required by state law where stricter.
• Pre-approval is required for overtime except in emergencies. Emergency overtime must be documented and justified to payroll within two business days.

On-call and telehealth rules

• Time spent on-call at home will be compensable if the employee’s ability to use the time for personal purposes is significantly restricted.
• Telehealth callbacks are compensable when they require the clinician to perform work (documenting care, prescribing, or patient triage). A minimum payment for call-outs should be defined to avoid disputes.

Monitoring and metrics to track compliance and wellbeing

Link compliance metrics to staff wellbeing indicators so legal and clinical leaders can see the human and financial stakes.

• Timekeeping compliance rate: percent of shifts with contemporaneous clock-ins/outs.
• Off-the-clock exception volume: number of recorded exceptions per pay period and trend direction.
• Overtime hours per FTE: baseline by role and department. Unusual spikes may signal understaffing.
• Back pay exposure estimate: rolling estimate based on audit findings.
• Burnout proxies: voluntary turnover, sick leave usage, and employee-reported work hours vs. paid hours.

Audit cadence

• Monthly operational checks for high-risk units (ED, behavioral health, home health) and quarterly enterprise-wide audits.
• Ad-hoc audits following complaints, union grievances, or large scheduling changes.

Technology and privacy considerations (2026 trends)

Technology can close many gaps but introduces new legal and ethical questions.

• Geofencing and mobile time capture are widely adopted for remote staff and home health. Ensure consent, transparent data use policies, and compliance with state biometrics and location privacy laws.
• EHR and timekeeping integration reduces discrepancies. Work with vendors to enable real-time alerts for suspected unpaid work (for example, chart access after clock-out).
• AI scheduling tools can reduce last-minute shift fills and predicted overtime but watch for algorithmic bias and legal challenges about automated discipline or schedule generation. Maintain human oversight.

Culture, communication, and staff wellbeing

Policy and tech fail without culture change. Protecting staff wellbeing reduces turnover, patient-safety risks, and litigation.

• Create an explicit “no off-the-clock work” culture backed by leadership examples. Senior clinicians and managers must model correct behavior.
• Provide protected time for documentation where possible; restructure workflows so charting is part of paid shift time.
• Offer rapid-access mental health resources and monitor workload intensity. Use recovery periods after extended shifts and avoid scheduling blocks that exacerbate fatigue.
• Include staff in policy design. Frontline input improves feasibility and compliance.

Handling complaints, investigations, and potential litigation

If a complaint or investigator contact occurs, move quickly but deliberately.

1. Preserve relevant records and limit external communications to central legal/HR contacts. Ensure robust backups and versioning as described in guides to automating safe backups and versioning.
2. Run a targeted audit matching complaint allegations. Produce reconciled payroll and time records promptly if lawful and required. For operational playbooks that cover onboarding, reconciliation and automation, see the advanced ops playbook.
3. Consider voluntary remediation when errors are clear. The DOL and many states consider good-faith remediation favorably in settlement discussions.
4. Document systemic fixes and follow-up audits, then communicate changes to staff to rebuild trust.

Case study: North Central Health Care (lessons learned)

The December 2025 consent judgment against North Central Health Care underlines several recurring errors:

• Failure to record all hours worked by case managers for a sustained period (June 2021–June 2023).
• Insufficient payroll reconciliation between time records and duties performed.
• Result: $81,243 in back wages and $81,243 in liquidated damages for 68 employees.

Lessons for employers:

• Proactive audits earlier could have limited exposure.
• Transparency and remediation are central—proving you corrected the cause helps in negotiations.
• Special attention is needed for case manager and care coordination roles that straddle clinical and administrative duties and are therefore often misclassified or under-tracked.

Checklist: 12-point compliance and wellbeing action plan

1. Initiate a 30–60 day payroll/timekeeping audit focused on high-risk roles.
2. Designate a single, integrated timekeeping system; reconcile with EHR logs.
3. Adopt or update written policies for hours worked, overtime, on-call, and telehealth compensability.
4. Institute manager and staff training on accurate time recording and anti-retaliation.
5. Set rules on rounding and document business justification.
6. Limit mandatory overtime and require documented pre-approval except in emergencies.
7. Implement technology safeguards—geofencing, mobile capture, and EHR integrations—with privacy protections.
8. Track KPIs: timekeeping compliance, overtime per FTE, exception volume, and burnout proxies.
9. Publish schedules with adequate notice; pay premiums for last-minute changes where required.
10. Formalize remediation playbook for discovered violations and communicate remedies promptly.
11. Involve employees in policy design to boost compliance and morale.
12. Schedule recurring audits and maintain documentation to show good-faith efforts.

Future-looking risks and recommendations for 2026 and beyond

Expect these trends to shape enforcement and employer practices:

• Increased regulatory focus on healthcare as a sector prone to off-the-clock work—more DOL investigations and state enforcement actions.
• Algorithmic scheduling scrutiny—courts and regulators will expect transparency about how automated systems set schedules and impact pay or discipline.
• Telehealth and distributed workforce risks—remote clinicians and home health staff create new time-tracking complexities.
• Data-driven defense—employers with clean, auditable records and documented corrective actions will fare better in investigations; consider long-term storage and cost strategies like storage cost optimization and interoperable verification approaches.

Recommendation: treat timekeeping as both a legal compliance program and a workforce health initiative. Investing in accurate pay practices pays back in staff retention, reduced litigation risk, and better patient care.

“Unchecked off-the-clock work is a compliance risk and a hidden contributor to burnout; addressing it is an operational, legal, and moral imperative.”

Final practical tools

Before closing, here are three quick tools leaders can deploy this week:

• Launch a single-issue staff survey asking: “How often do you finish patient documentation after clocking out?” Use anonymous responses to prioritize audits.
• Run a seven-day reconciliation for a high-risk unit comparing timekeeping logs vs. EHR access logs to find immediate discrepancies.
• Update timekeeping policy language and circulate a one-page manager checklist for approving adjustments.

Call to action

Take three steps today: (1) order a targeted payroll/timekeeping audit, (2) appoint an owner to update timekeeping and scheduling policies within 30 days, and (3) schedule manager training on off-the-clock rules. If you need a ready-to-use audit checklist or policy templates tailored to healthcare operations and 2026 regulatory expectations, contact your employment counsel or HR vendor and cite recent enforcement trends highlighted above.

Protecting staff wellbeing and preventing legal exposure start with reliable records, predictable schedules, and a culture that refuses unpaid work.

Related Reading

• Embedding observability into serverless clinical analytics
• How to audit and consolidate your tool stack before it becomes a liability
• Automating safe backups and versioning before letting AI tools touch your repositories
• 6 ways to stop cleaning up after AI: data engineering patterns
• From outage to SLA: reconciling vendor SLAs across Cloudflare, AWS, and SaaS
• Scent & Sight: Designing Aromatherapy Experiences for Art Lovers
• Eco-Forward Travel: How Manufactured Homes Are Changing Beachside Stays
• Creator Anxiety & On-Camera Confidence: Lessons from a D&D Performer
• Viral Fashion in Transit: Where to Spot (and Shop) the Viral Adidas 'Chinese' Jacket in Europe
• The Budget-Friendly Travel Office: Build an Affordable Editing Rig with a Discounted Mac mini and Peripherals